Myelinate
Mistakes worth studying

Why (a + b)² ≠ a² + b² — and how to stop writing it

A visual explanation, a quick numeric check, and a habit you can use today so you stop cancelling terms incorrectly.

6 min read

In this post
  1. A square that shows the missing 2ab
  2. Numeric check you can do in five seconds
  3. Where students actually go wrong on paper
  4. A safe expansion habit: multiply, don't “square” the pieces
  5. When the bad rule accidentally works
  6. Practice that trains the right eye
  7. Worked examples, worked fully
  8. Answer to the try-it
  9. What to do next (one specific action)

You hand in a test and the marker writes “lost method” next to the line (a+b)² = a² + b². The algebra looks neat. The answer is wrong. Here’s the one-line fix you can use on any paper: show the cross-terms once.

A square that shows the missing 2ab

Draw a square of side length (a+b). Its area is (a+b)². Split each side into lengths a and b and draw the two grid lines. You get four pieces whose areas add to the whole:

  • top-left: a×a = a²
  • top-right: a×b = ab
  • bottom-left: b×a = ab
  • bottom-right: b×b = b²

So

(a+b)2=a2+ab+ab+b2=a2+2ab+b2.(a+b)^2 = a^2 + ab + ab + b^2 = a^2 + 2ab + b^2.

If you erase the two ab rectangles from the picture you can literally see what’s missing. The equation a² + b² corresponds to keeping only the corner squares and discarding the middle pieces. That’s not algebra; that’s removing area. Look at how the two middle rectangles together make a strip across the square: they are not negligible and their size depends on both a and b.

The two ab pieces come from multiplying the a part of one factor by the b part of the other factor, and vice versa. Ignoring both products loses 2ab area. Because multiplication is commutative, the two cross-products ab and ba are equal and add to 2ab; forgetting that step is where most neat-looking but wrong answers come from.

Numeric check you can do in five seconds

If a rule feels too neat, test it with numbers. Try a=1, b=2.

(1+2)2=32=9.(1+2)^2 = 3^2 = 9. 12+22=1+4=5.1^2 + 2^2 = 1 + 4 = 5.

They differ: 9 − 5 = 4, and 4 = 2·1·2 = 2ab. Try two more quick checks.

  1. a=2, b=3:
(2+3)2=25,22+32=13,25−13=12=2⋅2⋅3.(2+3)^2 = 25, \quad 2^2 + 3^2 = 13, \quad 25-13 = 12 = 2\cdot2\cdot3.
  1. a=0, b=4:
(0+4)2=16,02+42=16.(0+4)^2 = 16, \quad 0^2 + 4^2 = 16.

They match only because ab = 0, so 2ab = 0. That’s a special case, not a justification of the general rule. Special or degenerate examples can hide mistakes; they can make a wrong general rule pass a couple of checks by accident.

A quick habit: when you see a claim you didn’t derive, plug in a=1, b=2. If it fails there, it’s false. If it holds, test more or prove it algebraically. Numeric checks catch bad steps fast; they don’t replace a proof. Also try boundary or trivial cases (a=0, b=0) to see whether a step relies on something that only holds for zero values.

Where students actually go wrong on paper

Students usually treat the exponent as if it distributes over addition and write (a+b)² = a² + b². There’s no rule that lets you apply the exponent to each summand separately. The exponent acts on the whole parenthesis.

Write the product instead and multiply:

(a+b)2=(a+b)(a+b)(a+b)^2 = (a+b)(a+b) (a+b)(a+b)=a⋅a+a⋅b+b⋅a+b⋅b(a+b)(a+b) = a\cdot a + a\cdot b + b\cdot a + b\cdot b =a2+ab+ab+b2=a2+2ab+b2.= a^2 + ab + ab + b^2 = a^2 + 2ab + b^2.

The bad step—skipping from (a+b)² to a² + b²—is the same as erasing the middle terms ab + ab. If a student removes terms without showing an operation (factor, cancel, add/subtract both sides), ask: what operation produced that simplification? If none is given, expand once to show the cross-terms. Teachers mark that missing line because it shows the thought: either you expanded and kept the cross-terms, or you have a reason they disappear.

A safe expansion habit: multiply, don't “square” the pieces

Make one habit and use it every time: when you see (sum)², rewrite it as a product and expand once, or write the formula, but always display the cross-terms at least once.

Two correct methods on the same example: expand (x+4)².

Method 1 — multiply:

(x+4)2=(x+4)(x+4)(x+4)^2 = (x+4)(x+4) =x⋅x+x⋅4+4⋅x+4⋅4= x\cdot x + x\cdot 4 + 4\cdot x + 4\cdot 4 =x2+4x+4x+16= x^2 + 4x + 4x + 16 =x2+8x+16.= x^2 + 8x + 16.

Method 2 — use the formula:

(x+4)2=x2+2⋅x⋅4+42=x2+8x+16.(x+4)^2 = x^2 + 2\cdot x \cdot 4 + 4^2 = x^2 + 8x + 16.

Both give the same result. The middle term 8x comes from 4x + 4x. If you skip that step mentally you may write x² + 16 and lose the 8x.

Write this short note on your paper: "show cross-terms once." Either put one expansion line, (a+b)(a+b), and expand, or write a² + 2ab + b² and underline 2ab so you don’t ignore it later. This habit is quick, visible, and it prevents a common slip that costs marks on tests.

When the bad rule accidentally works

Start from the correct formula and test the equality:

(a+b)2=a2+b2⟹a2+2ab+b2=a2+b2.(a+b)^2 = a^2 + b^2 \Longrightarrow a^2 + 2ab + b^2 = a^2 + b^2.

Subtract a² + b² from both sides:

2ab=0.2ab = 0.

So ab = 0. That means a = 0, b = 0, or both. Those are the only real cases where the middle term vanishes and the incorrect rule gives a correct number. If you see an example with a = 0 or b = 0, it can accidentally reinforce the wrong rule. That’s why you should test with nontrivial numbers.

Note: restricting to real numbers doesn't change this conclusion; the algebraic step 2ab = 0 is valid in any ring where zero divisors aren't hiding extra cases. For ordinary homework and tests with real numbers, ab = 0 means one factor is zero.

Practice that trains the right eye

Do these three short problems. Do the algebra and then a quick numeric check.

  1. Expand (x+3)².

(x+3)2=(x+3)(x+3)(x+3)^2 = (x+3)(x+3)

=x⋅x+x⋅3+3⋅x+3⋅3= x\cdot x + x\cdot 3 + 3\cdot x + 3\cdot 3

=x2+3x+3x+9= x^2 + 3x + 3x + 9

=x2+6x+9= x^2 + 6x + 9

Numeric check: x=2. Left: (2+3)² = 25. Right: 4 + 12 + 9 = 25. Watch for the wrong answer x² + 9, which drops 6x.

  1. Check whether (2+5)² = 2² + 5².

(2+5)² = 7² = 49.

2² + 5² = 4 + 25 = 29.

They differ by 20 = 2\cdot2\cdot5. Not equal.

  1. Find real a,b so that (a+b)² = a² + b².

Start: a² + 2ab + b² = a² + b². Subtract a² + b²: 2ab = 0. So ab = 0. Thus a = 0 or b = 0 (or both).

Common wrong answers here are claiming equality for all a,b or forgetting the step that produces 2ab. When you write your solution, circle the subtraction step: it is the move that isolates the cross-term and shows why the equality can hold only in trivial cases.

Try this before you scroll: expand (2x+3)² and check with x=1 numerically.

Answer below.

Worked examples, worked fully

Example 1: Expand (x+4)².

(x+4)² = (x+4)(x+4)

= x\cdot x + x\cdot 4 + 4\cdot x + 4\cdot 4

= x² + 4x + 4x + 16

= x² + 8x + 16.

Common wrong answer: x² + 16. That drops 4x + 4x = 8x.

Example 2: Show numerically that (1+2)² != 1² + 2².

(1+2)² = 9.

1² + 2² = 5.

9 − 5 = 4 = 2\cdot1\cdot2. The missing piece is 2ab.

Example 3: Find all real a,b such that (a+b)² = a² + b².

a² + 2ab + b² = a² + b² → 2ab = 0 → ab = 0. So a = 0 or b = 0.

Answer to the try-it

(2x+3)² = (2x+3)(2x+3)

= 2x\cdot 2x + 2x\cdot 3 + 3\cdot 2x + 3\cdot 3

= 4x² + 6x + 6x + 9

= 4x² + 12x + 9.

Numeric check at x=1: 4 + 12 + 9 = 25. Direct check: (2·1 + 3)² = 5² = 25.

What to do next (one specific action)

The next time you see a binomial square on a worksheet or test, write on your paper: “show cross-terms once” and immediately put one expansion line, either

(a+b)2=(a+b)(a+b)(a+b)^2 = (a+b)(a+b)

or

(a+b)2=a2+2ab+b2.(a+b)^2 = a^2 + 2ab + b^2.

Do that on your next three homework problems that include binomial squares. It takes two seconds and prevents losing marks for a slip you can catch in advance. If you want a quick readiness check for the algebra skills this post uses, try the free calculus readiness check. For more posts that tackle common algebra mistakes, see other posts on common algebra errors, or read about how the Myelinate program works if you want guided practice.

See which skills you’ve got and which you don’t

The free readiness check points you at what to work on next.

Take the check

Published November 10, 2026 by the Myelinate team.

Keep reading